Climate impact of soy
Soybeans have a terrible reputation in the climate debate. Primarily due to the South American soy, which in some cases comes from areas that used to be rainforests. When rainforest is cut down to produce soy, we lose biodiversity, and large composites of CO₂, stored in the wet forest floor, are released. When the so-called loss is calculated, it’s called Land Use Change – or LUC.
And as you have probably figured out by now, south American soy scores high on the LUC list. As does palm oil from Borneo’s rainforests.
When we increase soy production, soy oil production also increases. Soy oil has less of a LUC impact than palm oil from Borneo. So on other parameters, soy production compensates a bit by benefitting the Rainforest in Borneo. The indirect effect is called ILUC or indirect land use change.
That’s why LUC values are complex to calculate.
The Danish thinktank, CONCITO, has calculated the climate impact of soybean meal to be 3.8 kg CO₂e/kg. The global feed database, Global Feed Lifecycle Institute (GFLI), agrees. This database shows a value of 4.2 CO₂e/kg with LUC and 0,57 without LUC. So, LUC matters.
The Danish Pig Research Center uses data from GFLI, but states the climate impact of dry matter basis delivered in Denmark. They state 6.09 kg CO₂e/kg for soybean meal with LUC and 0.99 without.
The footprint increases if the soybean meal is refined to soy protein concentrate (SPC).
According to their calculations, soy protein concentrate accounts for 9.4 kg CO₂e/kg and 1.8 without LUC. So about 1 kg CO₂e/kg for the refinement process.
You cannot see the value for your own soy protein yet – the databases still use the same calculation regardless of brand and production method. So, for now, you will have to ask your protein supplier if you want to know the exact value of your feed.
What you can do in the databases is compare what different protein sources can do for your climate balance.
“Well, I can’t feed rapeseed meal to weaners!” you might be thinking.
“Sure, you can – when it’s fermented”.
Read more about the fermented rapeseed EP100i here.
But for other countries where soy is native (no Rainforest), soy makes perfect sense.
So, the protein source you feed your animals matters. How much it matters depends on legislation and CO₂ taxes, along with your access to locally produced protein.